Skip to content
Menu

Year 10 (ages 14–15, Grade 9 in the US) · English · Language Paper 1 reading · Lesson 3

Question 4: evaluating the text

How to answer Language Paper 1 Question 4 (15 marks): judging how successfully a writer creates an effect, with evaluative language and detailed references, practised on Scrooge and his nephew Fred.

Exam boards: this lesson matches the Pearson Edexcel GCSE English courses. Check which course your school follows.

Whiteboard video lesson: Question 4: evaluating the text

9-minute video lesson

Teaching, worked examples and 20 practice questions solved step by step.

Watch free for a month

What your child will learn

  • Unpick the Question 4 statement
  • Use evaluative language
  • Support judgements with detailed references
  • Plan a 15-mark answer in about 25 minutes

The method

  1. Underline what the writer is trying to create.
  2. Find three or four key moments across the lines.
  3. Judge how well each one works, with a quotation.
  4. Use evaluative words: effectively, vividly, convincingly.

Key words: evaluate, AO4, contrast, judgement, successfully.

Worked examples

Worked examples from the lesson, with every step.

Question 1

Statement: ‘The writer creates a contrast between Scrooge and Fred.’ What must you judge?

  1. Step 1: The contrast between them.
  2. Step 2: How successfully it is created.

Answer: how well Dickens contrasts Scrooge and Fred

Question 2

Evaluate Fred's greeting: ‘A merry Christmas, uncle! God save you!’

  1. Step 1: Exclamations; a blessing.
  2. Step 2: Instantly shows warmth and kindness.

Answer: it effectively establishes Fred as warm and generous

Question 3

Evaluate the description ‘his face was ruddy and handsome; his eyes sparkled’.

  1. Step 1: ‘ruddy’: healthy red; ‘sparkled’: life and joy.
  2. Step 2: Scrooge's ‘thin lips blue’ earlier.
  3. Step 3: A vivid contrast of warmth and cold.

Answer: the warm description makes Fred a vivid opposite of cold Scrooge