Year 10 (ages 14–15, Grade 9 in the US) · English · Language Paper 1 reading · Lesson 3
Question 4: evaluating the text
How to answer Language Paper 1 Question 4 (15 marks): judging how successfully a writer creates an effect, with evaluative language and detailed references, practised on Scrooge and his nephew Fred.
Exam boards: this lesson matches the Pearson Edexcel GCSE English courses. Check which course your school follows.

9-minute video lesson
Teaching, worked examples and 20 practice questions solved step by step.
Watch free for a monthWhat your child will learn
- Unpick the Question 4 statement
- Use evaluative language
- Support judgements with detailed references
- Plan a 15-mark answer in about 25 minutes
The method
- Underline what the writer is trying to create.
- Find three or four key moments across the lines.
- Judge how well each one works, with a quotation.
- Use evaluative words: effectively, vividly, convincingly.
Key words: evaluate, AO4, contrast, judgement, successfully.
Worked examples
Worked examples from the lesson, with every step.
Question 1
Statement: ‘The writer creates a contrast between Scrooge and Fred.’ What must you judge?
- Step 1: The contrast between them.
- Step 2: How successfully it is created.
Answer: how well Dickens contrasts Scrooge and Fred
Question 2
Evaluate Fred's greeting: ‘A merry Christmas, uncle! God save you!’
- Step 1: Exclamations; a blessing.
- Step 2: Instantly shows warmth and kindness.
Answer: it effectively establishes Fred as warm and generous
Question 3
Evaluate the description ‘his face was ruddy and handsome; his eyes sparkled’.
- Step 1: ‘ruddy’: healthy red; ‘sparkled’: life and joy.
- Step 2: Scrooge's ‘thin lips blue’ earlier.
- Step 3: A vivid contrast of warmth and cold.
Answer: the warm description makes Fred a vivid opposite of cold Scrooge