Year 10 (ages 14–15, Grade 9 in the US) · English · AQA Language Paper 1 · Lesson 4
AQA Language Paper 1, Question 4: evaluating a statement
How to answer AQA Language Paper 1 Question 4 (20 marks): decide how far you agree with a student's statement about part of the source, then support your view with quotations and analysis of how the writer creates that impression.
Exam boards: this lesson matches the AQA GCSE English courses. Check which course your school follows.

9-minute video lesson
Teaching, worked examples and 20 practice questions solved step by step.
Watch free for a monthWhat your child will learn
- Understand what Question 4 asks
- Give a clear, personal judgement
- Support it with evidence and analysis
- Write a well-organised evaluative answer in 20 minutes
The method
- Split the statement into its parts.
- Decide how far you agree.
- Find 3–4 quotations for each part.
- Analyse how the writer creates the impression.
- Keep returning to the statement with evaluative words.
Key words: evaluate, statement, impression, judgement, to what extent.
Worked examples
Worked examples from the lesson, with every step.
Question 1
What does ‘to what extent do you agree’ mean?
- Step 1: How much do you agree: fully, mostly, partly, or not at all?
Answer: say how far you agree, and why
Question 2
Find evidence that Mara might be trapped.
- Step 1: It ‘stuck’; she had to force it.
- Step 2: She is ‘halfway up’ narrow steps in the dark.
Answer: the stuck door and her position halfway up dark stairs
Question 3
Find evidence that she is NOT fully trapped.
- Step 1: She chose to enter, and nothing blocks her way down.
Answer: she chose to go in and could still go back down