Skip to content
Menu

Year 10 (ages 14–15, Grade 9 in the US) · English · AQA Language Paper 1 · Lesson 4

AQA Language Paper 1, Question 4: evaluating a statement

How to answer AQA Language Paper 1 Question 4 (20 marks): decide how far you agree with a student's statement about part of the source, then support your view with quotations and analysis of how the writer creates that impression.

Exam boards: this lesson matches the AQA GCSE English courses. Check which course your school follows.

Whiteboard video lesson: AQA Language Paper 1, Question 4: evaluating a statement

9-minute video lesson

Teaching, worked examples and 20 practice questions solved step by step.

Watch free for a month

What your child will learn

  • Understand what Question 4 asks
  • Give a clear, personal judgement
  • Support it with evidence and analysis
  • Write a well-organised evaluative answer in 20 minutes

The method

  1. Split the statement into its parts.
  2. Decide how far you agree.
  3. Find 3–4 quotations for each part.
  4. Analyse how the writer creates the impression.
  5. Keep returning to the statement with evaluative words.

Key words: evaluate, statement, impression, judgement, to what extent.

Worked examples

Worked examples from the lesson, with every step.

Question 1

What does ‘to what extent do you agree’ mean?

  1. Step 1: How much do you agree: fully, mostly, partly, or not at all?

Answer: say how far you agree, and why

Question 2

Find evidence that Mara might be trapped.

  1. Step 1: It ‘stuck’; she had to force it.
  2. Step 2: She is ‘halfway up’ narrow steps in the dark.

Answer: the stuck door and her position halfway up dark stairs

Question 3

Find evidence that she is NOT fully trapped.

  1. Step 1: She chose to enter, and nothing blocks her way down.

Answer: she chose to go in and could still go back down